Go to app

Rating AI messages

Give your bird's replies a thumbs up or down, with a short reason, to shape how it talks to every lead. Explanations are 35 to 300 characters.

Written by the EarlyBird team

Last verified Nov 4, 2026

Watch the video walkthrough (opens in a new tab)

Your bird's job is to engage new leads, answer their questions and get you on a call. Rating its messages is how you shape the way it speaks, so it always acts the way you'd approve of. Even a well-meaning bird can say things you'd rather it didn't, like implying you have unlimited availability. That's what feedback is for.

Feedback teaches your bird globally. A rating you leave in one room shapes how it handles every future conversation, not just that one.

Rate a message

  1. In Messenger → Inbox, open a room.
  2. Hover over a message your bird sent. Its messages have an AI label.
  3. Click the thumbs up if you like it, or the thumbs down if something's off.
  4. Pick one or more reasons.
  5. Explain why in the box. Be specific.
  6. Click Save.

The window shows the message you're rating under Message, so you can quote it in your explanation.

The reasons you can pick

Thumbs up: "What did you like about this message?"Thumbs down: "What was wrong with this message?"
The Tone of this Message is GreatI Don't Like the Tone of This Message
Another ReasonOvercommited to Work
This Message Has Wrong Information
Another Reason

You must pick at least one. If you don't, you'll see "Please select at least one reason".

Write an explanation that works

Your explanation must be at least 35 characters and at most 300 characters. Shorter, you'll see "Explanation must be at least 35 characters". Longer: "Explanation cannot exceed 300 characters". Leave it empty and you'll see "Explanation is required".

  • Name the one thing that matters. "Not good" gives your bird nothing to work with. Say exactly what was wrong, or what you'd rather it said.
  • Upvote what works. When your bird handles something well, say so: "Great way to introduce a call without being pushy. Keep this approach."
  • Downvote what doesn't. If a message said "I'm available and can work as many hours as needed", you might write: "Don't ever tell clients I have unlimited hours. Always save that conversation for after we've connected on a call."
  • Use both thumbs. Your bird learns from what's right as much as from what's wrong.

Rate early

The first handful of conversations you review make the biggest difference. Once your bird has a clear picture of your voice and preferences, it should make good choices on its own. A little time up front pays off every time a lead writes in while you're away.

If you keep giving the same feedback, turn it into a rule in Settings → Messenger instead. See Teaching your bird your tone and voice and Guardrails: never do or say, and when to escalate.

Change or delete a rating

A rated message keeps its thumbs on show, with the one you picked highlighted. You can rate each message once.

  1. Hover over the rated message.
  2. Click the trash icon.
  3. Confirm "Delete feedback submission?".

To change a rating, delete it and rate the message again.

Messages you can't rate

Thumbs only appear on messages sent from your side of the conversation. Some of those can't be rated, and hovering over the thumbs tells you why:

  • Your cover letter: "You can't leave feedback for your cover letter. Change this in your bidders". See Writing your cover letter template.
  • Other items, such as meeting invites and offers: "Not eligible for feedback".